General Synopsis from Waterstones Marketplace http://www.waterstonesmarketplace.com - no longer active. About this title:The fighting arts of Indonesia, a mix of pentjak silat and Chinese kuntao, were never meant for sport: they are brutal, unrelenting and designed to take the enemy out and punish him every step of the way. This unprecedented book by a long-time student of Dutch-Indonesian Master Willem de Thouars shows you why. Note: This is a general synopsis.
|
|
|
For myself (Bob Orlando), the following is the best review I could ever receive for this book. That is why it is here, at the top Reviews that follow it are listed chronologically from most recent to oldest. |
|
|
Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Oh.. so that what it actually means I only learned Pencak Silat for two months in high school, simply because it was part of the curriculum. Some Sundanese style I don't even know the name. Like many other Indonesians I know, I considered pencak silat as silly, ineffective, traditional, etc. ... in short, learn karate, jujitsu, tae kwon do, or any other martial art... but not silat... (shame on us, but it is the popular perception). Reading this book I looked back at the only two jurus I know, and realized that there was more in there than some silly dance... Now I am a proud Indonesian. However, I doubt that many Indonesian masters really understand the materials they are teaching... this is really a remarkable work of Indonesian art from Western perspective. A great thank you to Mr. Orlando. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Bob made complicated Silat topics easy to understand I have studied a variety of martial arts over the past twenty years. While I have had limited exposure to Silat, I find it fascinating. A few years ago, I read Indonesian Fighting Fundamentals by Bob Orlando. Bob made complicated Silat topics easy to understand. I have reread the book several times now and I always find something I missed. Even if you don't practice Silat, this book will probably show you something you didn't understand in another art. The deeper your knowledge in the martial arts, the more they all start to blend together. I recently took a business trip to Colorado and asked Bob if I could come train at his school. I was surprised when Bob agreed. Bob spent the class working with me one on one sharing his ideas, philosophy, techniques, and humor. Bob is a great martial artist, teacher, and human being. I don't give out my recommendations lightly, but this book deserves a spot in every martial artists library. Thank you, Bob!
Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Must Buy Easy to read and understand, yet has technical information. Will add to anyone's knowledge of martial arts!
Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
I recommend this book to students of other arts
Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Nothing Exciting Really basic book, nothing of real interest. Maybe this book would be ok for a rank novice.
No depth, really skims over important concepts. You could easily read this information on the internet
for free. The book does go deep into how dangerous and great Indonesian martial arts are. Don't
waste your time. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Indonesian Fighting Book This book is an outstanding book. Well developed and full of valuable information for those with
interest in history as well as basic fundamental techniques. Guru Orlando did a great job with his main
objective, providing the fundamentals of the Indonesian fighting arts. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Excellent book. It definitely gave me more insight to the Indonesian fighting arts.
I would recommend to anyone interested in this system. eBay My World, Member Review:
One of the BEST! Indonesian Fighting Fundamentals by Bob Orlando is truly one of the best books to date to
tackle the some what esoteric systems of Kuntao and Silat. As well as giving an excellent education
to all martial artists about universal principles that can be applied directly to any fighting style.
This book is a most for all serious students of the Warrior Way. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
An Excellent Book This is the best book I've ever seen on the principles and application of "Indonesian" arts. You can't learn to fight from a book, of course, but you can get some good ideas. If these arts interest you, or you are training in Kali or Silat (or any fighting art, for that matter),
this is a fun book to read. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Excellent book on principles in Kuntao and Silat I have to agree with the review of Joseph Burtner. This is an OUTSTANDING book on some of the principles used in Kuntao and Silat. Very well written, clear and understandable. This book immediately took a place on the "top shelf" of my martial arts library. There is a
companion DVD to this book that meshes very well with it and gives a visual demonstration of the
principles. It's called "Fighting Arts of Indonesia - Combat Secrets of Silat and Kuntao"
and you can find it on Amazon. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Not Worth The Price I bought this book hoping I would pick up on some new techniques, principles or concepts I could integrate into my style. Which is based on Karate, Jeet kune do, akido, and kung fu. I did pick up on some things I could combine with my system. However, I don't think the book or the system is worth all the hype that has been given to it. I guess its just because the system is so limited from my point of view. . . . Some may say this is a grown up book for black belts. That may be. I'm a black belt and
I don't think . . . Sure I picked up a few new concepts and principles that I may be able
to apply to my style but I don't think those few concepts were worth the money I paid for the book.
If it covered all possible types of attacks from other styles, and combined leg tactics the book would be
worth the money but, I feel the "style" falls short of "Real" combat situations you may find yourself
in. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Great alternative reference for traditional karate kata students The ideas presented in this book are thought provoking for all martial artists, especially practioners
of traditonal karate. Once put into actual practice, these ideas open a new path to the interpretation
of kata. A must have for everyone. Journal of Asian Martial Arts
Media Review -- by Kirstin Pauka, Ph.D.,
This book is a valuable handbook for practitioners of Indonesian pencak silat.
The stated purpose of the book is to present fighting principles found in various styles of silat
and kuntao as taught by Dutch-Indonesian masters. It provides a much needed description and
analysis of techniques, methods, and tactics, as well as underlying principles.
Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
No Matter Your Level, You'll Like This! Here we have a decent depiction of how the various arts of the Archipelago may be practiced.
It is more of a tactics and principles book than a mere techniques catalog, so it will appeal to those
who have been in the arts for some years, as well as those who are simply striving for deeper understanding
of the basics. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Another great book, but ..... I really liked the book but was disappointed by the fact that the author left out lots of history and info on the "mystical" side of Pentjak [emphasis added]. His reason though for doing this is that he is a Christian and doesn't believe in chi or the mystical stuff. I do understand and respect his decision in doing so. The book does show not really techniques but rather drills to understand body movement from which all techniques come form. Overall it's very recommended for simplicity in explaining the flow and feel of Pentjak Silat. Again no disrespect for the author or his choice of worship.
A fair criticism. Perhaps the following paragraphs (the first from the book's Introduction, and the second from Magic and Mysticism chapter) from will explain why I omitted history and the "mystical" side of Pentjak. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Outstanding; well worth the price This well-written, easy to read tome is a thinking martial artist's book. It is filled with sound
principles and great explanations of why they work so effectively in actual combat. There's some
techniques too, but that's not really the heart of this tome. Pentjak silat and kuntao are, at their
core, functional fighting arts and Sifu Orlando is master of these brutal styles. He places rarely
divulged applications in context, artfully explaining why and how they work. I wasn't too keen on
his work Martial Arts America so
I held off on buying this one for quite some time. Having finally gotten around to reading it I
really wish I'd bought this one sooner. I am thoroughly impressed with this outstanding volume
even at its rather steep price. Very highly recommended! BarnesAndNoble.com, Customer Reviews:
Best Silat Book This is an excellent book on silat. The pictures are very clear,
as is the writing, and the explanation of concepts. I love the fact that the author is pragmatic
and not dogmatic in his approach to martial arts. This is an 'exotic' martial art, but is extremely
practical, especially because most fights are at extreme close range, and silat is very good in the
grappling range. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
One Of The Best Self Defense Books Available Bob Orlando did a great job on this book. The contents of the book is primarily a blend of Kun Tao-Silat. I trained in the Indonesian martial arts some, by way of Hanshi Bruce Juchnik, who like Bob Orlando, studied the Indonesian Martial Arts from Willem de Thouars. Bob has also trained in many other martial arts. Guro Dennis Servaes Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
The principles are essential The title is a little deceiving. This book doesn't really profile silat or kuntao.
Rather, it is one of the best books on concepts that I've ever read. I'd place it up there with
"Tao of Jeet Kune Do". The concepts of gyroscopic rotation, shearing, adhesion, etc. can be
applied to any art, given a little imagination. While the reader will learn something on the
history of Indonesian martial arts, it is really the underlying principle that receive the most
attention. One won't really learn HOW to do silat or kuntao, but will gain an understanding
of WHY the practitioners of such arts do the things they do. There is nothing on weapons,
which I thought was strange, and nothing on Kali, which I thought was Indonesian, but that doesn't
take away from the fact that this is one of the best books on martial arts principles out there.
No matter whether one is looking for aesthetics, self-defense, understanding the "arts", or sporting
aspects of martial arts, there is something in this book for everyone. I'd recommend it to
anyone serious about the martial arts, but those with a more casual attitude towards the arts may not
find anything useful here. If I could only have five martial arts books, this would be one of them. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
One of The All Time Best Yes a bit pricey, but worth every cent. I have been through the tape that goes with the book,
and the tapes on Reflex training drills. Mr. Orlando
is on the cutting edge with only a handful of other martial artists. I teach Aikido. After 911,
I was not happy anymore with what and how I was teaching, so I am trying to integrate some of the principles
and techniques (yes you can see several if you watch the tapes long enough — oh, and read the book) into what
and how I teach. GREAT STUFF!!!! Larry Hartsell's books (have 4 of them)
are very very good also, but in a different context. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
An Excellent Overview of Fighting/Movement Concepts Author Bob Orlando has written something which is sadly rare these days: a martial arts book for people
who think. If like many, you scan through a book and just look at the pictures, you will probably be
unimpressed with the volume of techniques. If,on the other hand, you actually READ this book, you
will be presented with material which cannot help but enhance the martial art which you practice.
. . . I held off on buying this book for years (primarily because of the price), but now I
could kick myself for procrastinating. This book is written in a straightforward and reader-friendly
style, and the photos are large enough and show enough contrast to clearly demonstrate the ideas
represented. I'm kind of stingy with five star ratings, but this book is clearly deserving.
... full review Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
One of the best martial arts books I've ever read The book does an excellent job of teaching several important fundamental principles of Silat and Kuntao and using techniques to demonstrate how they work. Regardless of what style you study, an understanding of these principles and how to apply them will make you a more effective martial artist. I also highly recommend Bob Orlando's video, "Fighting Arts of Indonesia - Combat Secrets of Silat and Kuntao"
which makes a great companion to the book. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Great Book This is an excellent book on concepts of how to become a more proficient fighter. If you're looking for a book full of techniques, this in not the book for you. This book instead gives you the "ABC's of fighting." What I mean by the "ABC's of fighting" is that there are 26 letters in the alphabet, but the words that can be created from those 26 characters are endless. That is what this does by giving you a solid foundation to build upon. Also, I bought this book because it was recommended by two other authors that I respect a great deal
-- Marc MacYoung and Alain Burrese. From Belgium: Wim Demeere
This book is an excellent example of what authors should more often do: Instead of just rehashing the
same material (the principles), Bob gives you much more information on several topics that aren't included
in the video. As a result, both the book and video are excellent companions for each other.
You can read the book and then see the principles come to life in the video. However, once you've
seen all this, there is even more to ponder when reading.
... full Review Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
The techniques are good, but there are only a few in this book. A person would be better off to buy Larry Hartsell's 2 books on Jeet Kune Do. They contain the information in this book and about 10 times more and you'll have some change left over!
Despite the 387 photographs and drawings used to illustrate this work, this anonymous reviewer is correct, "there are only a few [techniques] in this book." The book is, as repeatedly stated in its introduction, about principles. Learn and understand the principles of fighting, and the number of techniques you can create on your own will fill volumes. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Principles of Effective Self-Defense Bob Orlando is that rarest of commodities: a teacher who has the analytical skills and intelligence
to distil his martial art(s) into a handful of principles from which effective martial techniques may
be generated. This book, and the companion video, Fighting Arts of Indonesia, are masterful
communications of this material. Buy them and learn. Journal of Asian Martial Arts
Media Review — by Aurther C. Andersen,
Bob Orlando has organized a very concise package of physical principles indicative of martial movement
as imparted from his instructor, Willem de Thouars. He has not tried to offer a comprehensive
history of Indonesian martial arts, but instead, gives colorfully detailed representations of the techniques
which comprise the basic repertoire of his interpretation of Indonesian fighting fundamentals.
... full review Review Page: Indonesian Fighting Fundamentals
If you train in any South East asian martial art then this book is an essential read. It covers the art of Willem de Thouars ... The book is almost totally devoid of any specialist terminology, I think that there are only two Indonesian words used throughout the entire text, this makes it very accessible to almost any reader. ... Verdict: highly recommended.
... full review Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
A Rare Martial Arts Book That You Can Actually Learn From It's rare indeed that a martial arts book can teach a reader much that they can incorporate into their own practice: usually the techniques that they teach are too difficult to learn from a book, or so simple that any student knows them already. But by focusing on principles and logic of combat rather than on specific techniques, Bob Orlando gives the student of martial arts not only insight into Indonesian styles but methods of practice and training which a student of virtually any art can incorporate into their own. In addition, this book is an excellent companion to Orlando's video "Fighting Arts of Indonesia". They cover much of the same ground and reinforce each other. It had an immediate and transformative impact on my martial arts training. Without a doubt, this is the most useful martial arts book I have
ever purchased. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
My copy is dog-eared. This is not a book that you read just once. It is a well of information that you will continue to
return to again and again. Everytime I read it I come away with new understanding of the depths of
martial arts. No matter what style you study, the principles here will help you better understand
your own art.
Marc MacYoung is an ex-streetfighter turned prolific author with several books and videos on violence, self-defense, and survival to his credit. Amazon.UK, Customer Reviews:
It's about time, this stuff is held back from most Westerners The other reviews I have read are obviously from those unfamiliar with kun tao/silat.
Infighting is what these arts are known for, and as far as entering techniques are concerned, if you need
to ask then this book went way over your head. Amazon.com, Customer Reviews:
Physical principles for effective infighting Indonesian Fighting Fundamentals (IFF for short) is a different from your average martial arts
book. You won't find a collection of techniques or "moves" that will make you a better fighter.
Rather you will find a collection of physical principles that are the foundation of many of the techniques
of Silat and Kuntao which are the major systems covered in this book.
... full review Review Page: Indonesian Fighting Fundamentals
This book was written by Bob Orlando, who is a long time student of Master Willem de Thouars.
This book addresses just what the title implies. ... the fundamentals of the Indonesian
Arts. I love the fact that he concentrates on the concepts of these arts, and doesn't get hung up on
just giving us techniques. With the concepts, you can make up your own combinations!
"Give a man a fish, and feed him for a day: teach him to fish, feed him for a lifetime."
Five out of five stars. Journal of Asian Martial Arts
Media Review — by James Wilson, L.Ac.,
Orlando writes that his intent is not "a detailing [of] the history, culture, or many fighting systems
of Indonesia ..., [but] is intended primarily for the martial art student of any rank whose main reason for
training and study is effective self-defense" to this end he has succeeded marvelously. The author
accurately portrays the use of a wide variety of Indonesian strikes and stances, effectively demonstrating
their differences with other fighting styles, the principles behind their actions, and their use in combat
situations. His own sometimes creative terminology — my personal favorite being "gyroscopic rotation"
— actually enhances the student's understanding than if the author had attempted to translate those actions
described directly from the Indonesian. Similarly, Indonesian Fighting Fundamentals is clearly
illustrated, with just the right number of photographs and graphics accompanied by clear, concise
captions. In this respect, many martial arts authors should consider Orlando's work exemplary.
...
full review Triumph Magazine
Indonesian Fighting Fundamentals: The Brutal Arts of the Archipelago, undertakes to explain to
readers something about the martial arts of the Indonesian archipelago. I approached the book with
some apprehension, as I wondered just what benefit someone whose martial art background included no
training in Indonesian arts at all, could really obtain from a "how to" book about an
unfamiliar martial art. Fortunately for me, and for all others lucky enough to spend some time
with Orlando's Indonesian Fighting Fundamentals, the book is decidedly anything but another book
on how to perform martial techniques. Quite the contrary, ...
full review |
|
©Copyright Bob Orlando, 1999-2016 All rights reserved. |
http://www.OrlandoKuntao.com
E-mail: Ron@OrlandoKuntao.com |
Last update:
Aug. 6, 2016 by Bob Orlando |